Affordable Custom Engagement Rings | Under $5000

Custom doesn’t have to mean out of reach. Our affordable custom engagement rings are handcrafted in the USA with premium stones and fine materials—without the markup. We believe meaningful, luxurious rings should be accessible. Because love is priceless—and your ring doesn’t need to be.

Filters0

Filters

Colombian Green Emerald pear shaped 3 stone engagement ring with elegant diamond side stones.

Colombian Green Emerald 3 stone pear diamond ring set in a delicate band.

Woman wearing pear shaped three stone engagement ring with romantic flair.

Pear Shape Lab Grown Colombian Emerald and Diamond Three Stone Ring in 14k Gold

$749.00

Seven stone diamond ring for women celebrating everlasting love with gemstones.

7 diamond anniversary band in gold, a popular choice for ladies anniversary rings featuring gemstones.

Gold anniversary ring with seven gemstones and diamonds for timeless elegance.

Alternating Oval Shape Lab Grown Ruby and Diamond Seven Stone Scalloped Ring in 14k Gold

$729.00

Asscher cut three stone engagement ring with geometric elegance.

Asscher gemstone diamond ring with step-cut sparkle in a three stone setting featuring yellow sapphire center.

Woman wearing a 3 stone Asscher engagement ring with vintage flair featuring a yellow sapphire center.

New

3.25 Carats Asscher Cut Lab Grown Yellow Sapphire and Trapezoid Diamond Ring in 14k Gold

$879.00

Asscher gemstone diamond ring with step-cut sparkle in a three stone setting featuring ruby center.

Woman wearing a 3 stone Asscher engagement ring with vintage flair featuring a ruby center.

New

3.25 Carats Asscher Cut Lab Grown Ruby and Trapezoid Diamond Ring in 14k Gold

$879.00

Asscher gemstone diamond ring with step-cut sparkle in a three stone setting featuring pink sapphire center.

Woman wearing a 3 stone Asscher engagement ring with vintage flair featuring a pink sapphire center.

New

3.25 Carats Asscher Cut Lab Grown Pink Sapphire and Trapezoid Diamond Ring in 14k Gold

$879.00

Asscher gemstone diamond ring with step-cut sparkle in a three stone setting featuring paraiba tourmaline center.

Woman wearing a 3 stone Asscher engagement ring with vintage flair featuring a paraiba tourmaline center.

New

3 Carats Asscher Cut Lab Grown Paraiba Tourmaline and Trapezoid Diamond Ring in 14k Gold

$949.00

Asscher gemstone diamond ring with step-cut sparkle in a three stone setting featuring colombian emerald center.

Woman wearing a 3 stone Asscher engagement ring with vintage flair featuring a colombian emerald center.

New

2 Carats Asscher Cut Lab Grown Colombian Emerald and Trapezoid Diamond Ring in 14k Gold

$949.00

Asscher gemstone diamond ring with step-cut sparkle in a three stone setting featuring blue sapphire center.

Woman wearing a 3 stone Asscher engagement ring with vintage flair featuring a blue sapphire center.

New

3.25 Carats Asscher Cut Lab Grown Blue Sapphire and Trapezoid Diamond Ring in 14k Gold

$879.00

New

3.25 Carats Asscher Cut Lab Grown Yellow Sapphire and Kite Diamond Ring in 14k Gold

$829.00

New

3.25 Carats Asscher Cut Lab Grown Ruby and Kite Diamond Ring in 14k Gold

$829.00

New

3.25 Carats Asscher Cut Lab Grown Pink Sapphire and Kite Diamond Ring in 14k Gold

$829.00

New

3 Carats Asscher Cut Lab Grown Paraiba Tourmaline and Kite Diamond Ring in 14k Gold

$879.00

New

2 Carats Asscher Cut Lab Grown Colombian Emerald and Kite Diamond Ring in 14k Gold

$879.00

New

3.25 Carats Asscher Cut Lab Grown Blue Sapphire and Kite Diamond Ring in 14k Gold

$829.00

Cushion cut 3 stone engagement ring with soft corners and vintage charm.

Cushion shaped engagement ring with brilliant diamonds and yellow gemstone.

Woman wearing a cushion cut 3 stone ring with romantic styling featuring yellow gemstone and diamonds.

New

3.25 Carats Cushion Cut Lab Grown Yellow Sapphire and Trapezoid Diamond Ring in 14k Gold

$879.00

Cushion shaped engagement ring with brilliant diamonds and red gemstone.

Woman wearing a cushion cut 3 stone ring with romantic styling featuring red gemstone and diamonds.

New

3.25 Carats Cushion Cut Lab Grown Ruby and Trapezoid Diamond Ring in 14k Gold

$879.00

Cushion shaped engagement ring with brilliant diamonds and pink gemstone.

Woman wearing a cushion cut 3 stone ring with romantic styling featuring pink gemstone and diamonds.

New

3.25 Carats Cushion Cut Lab Grown Pink Sapphire and Trapezoid Diamond Ring in 14k Gold

$879.00

Cushion shaped engagement ring with brilliant diamonds and green gemstone.

Woman wearing a cushion cut 3 stone ring with romantic styling featuring green gemstone and diamonds.

New

3 Carats Cushion Cut Lab Grown Paraiba Tourmaline and Trapezoid Diamond Ring in 14k Gold

$949.00

New

2 Carats Cushion Cut Lab Grown Emerald and Trapezoid Diamond Ring in 14k Gold

$879.00

New

2.50 Carats Cushion Cut Lab Grown Colombian Emerald and Trapezoid Diamond Ring in 14k Gold

$949.00

Cushion shaped engagement ring with brilliant diamonds and blue gemstone.

Woman wearing a cushion cut 3 stone ring with romantic styling featuring blue gemstone and diamonds.

New

3.25 Carats Cushion Cut Lab Grown Blue Sapphire and Trapezoid Diamond Ring in 14k Gold

$879.00

Cushion shaped engagement ring with brilliant diamonds and alexandrite gemstone.

Woman wearing a cushion cut 3 stone ring with romantic styling featuring alexandrite gemstone and diamonds.

New

3 Carats Cushion Cut Lab Grown Alexandrite and Trapezoid Diamond Ring in 14k Gold

$999.00

New

3.25 Carats Cushion Cut Lab Grown Yellow Sapphire and Princess Cut Diamond Ring in 14k Gold

$799.00

New

3.25 Carats Cushion Cut Lab Grown Ruby and Princess Cut Diamond Ring in 14k Gold

$799.00

“
She cried when she opened the box.
I wanted something that didn’t exist yet—an engagement ring with a teal sapphire in a vintage-inspired setting. Pel & Co. made it happen, and it’s even more beautiful than I imagined. Thank you for making this moment unforgettable.
”

David R.

San Francisco, CA

“
I always assumed custom engagement rings were out of my budget, but Pel & Co. was so transparent with pricing. I got to choose the exact gemstone and design every detail, and it didn’t break the bank. It looks like a ring twice the price
”

Emily S.

Chicago, IL

“
We came to Pel & Co. with a very specific idea—using a family sapphire and turning it into something modern. They didn’t just design a ring; they brought our family history to life. It’s now a part of our future too.
”

Hannah & Noah

Brooklyn, NY

Cart 0

No more products available for purchase

Filters0